Why Miss Marple Matters*

Marple, as she appeared in volume 20 of Case C...

Image via Wikipedia

*Everyone needs a rest day, right?  As it is in running, so it is in life.  So tonight, I bring you a guest post from Nat, the greatest feminist fiancé a gal could ask for.

Why Miss Marple Matters


The Curious Case of the Miss Marple Movie

Disney has a long history of turning classic stories into mass-market products. Walt himself drew the teeth out of dark folktales, and gave us “happily ever after” in place of tradition, meaning, and complexity. So it should come as no surprise that Disney has recently announced a “reboot” of Agatha Christie’s classic sleuth, Miss Marple. In the new Disney version, Miss Marple will be given a “young spin” by Jennifer Garner.

So what? Why does this matter? To answer those questions, let’s take a step back and look at Miss Marple – the original Marple conceived of by Agatha Christie. For those who aren’t mystery readers she probably occupies a vague spot in the cultural consciousness with the words elderly, spinster, and detective somehow coming together to form a picture of an old busy body, hunched over her knitting, popping up occasionally to solve a convoluted crime. And that vague impression is what Disney hopes to counter with Jennifer Garner. But Miss Marple should be a more important figure for women than that caricature suggests.

Agatha Christie began writing Miss Marple stories in 1927 and continued to do so regularly until 1971. Jane Marple was indeed a spinster who loved gardening and knitting, but more importantly she was an iconoclast. Jane Marple was a woman who defied both convention and expectation. Any woman of advanced middle age in mid 20th century England (or America for that matter) would have been seen as someone to be indulged, condescended to, dismissed, but never as a person capable of challenging the authority of men.

Jane Marple subverted the social structure by using those expectations against the very people she was trying to catch. She lured suspects into divulging secrets, feigned innocent concern when digging for information, and on many occasions used the camouflage of the old, pottering, spinster to uncover vital information. Her chief weapon against the schemes of brutal murderers was her keen intellect so cunningly disguised.

The murderers she helped to catch disrupted the social order with the chaos of their crimes. They upset the comfortable civility that living in a common society allows us. Jane Marple helped repair the order by finding the truth and bringing justice, but what makes her such a brilliant character is that in the end we are left with Agatha Christie’s unsettling subtext — if that social order was true and right, then a woman like Jane Marple shouldn’t be possible. Through Jane Marple, Agatha Christie questioned society’s restrictions on what women were capable of.

By “re-imagining” the older Jane Marple as a young Jennifer Garner, Disney negates much of Agatha Christie’s powerful message by promoting the all too common Hollywood message that a woman’s worth is judged first and foremost by her physical appearance. Jane Marple will no longer stand as an example of the many different ways women can be masterful and powerful. Instead she will become just another example of how the media driven cult of beauty marginalizes the beautiful minds and spirits of all women. Scheming, ruthless murderers couldn’t stop Jane Marple, but Disney has casually cut the heart out of an enduring feminist role model.

Enhanced by Zemanta


  1. At least it’s not Angelina Jolie. Should be Maggie Smith or Helen Mirren. But at least it’s not Scarlet Johannsen or Carey Mulligan or Emma Watson or … God, the nightmares.

  2. I don’t see why so many marole fans are having such a fit that miss garner will be the new miss marple. Claiming it destroys the idea of what Miss Christie creates as Miss Marple in an earlier era. The last new productions have surely veered from Miss Christie’s true portrayal of acceptable behavior and British culture at that time by adding homosexual characters that could not have possibly behaved that way in that era of time. Although its clear people have been gay for decades it just would not have been openly displayed or accepted in British Society or Culture in those days as it was portrayed in the last production of “The Body in the Library” so it is hypocritical of all those Marple fans complaIning about Miss Garner being cast. Lets not forget that the young Miss Marple’s true love was a married man. Miss Garner will make a wonderful young Jane Marple.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s